Planning for retirement is vital to financial well-being, and understanding the various available investment account options is crucial. In this article, we will compare and contrast the pension systems in the United Kingdom (UK) and the United States (US), focusing on UK pensions and US 401(k)s. By examining their features, contributions, taxation, and benefits, we aim to analyse these retirement savings vehicles comprehensively.
Pensions (UK) and 401ks (US)
Structure and Purpose
UK Pensions: In the UK, pensions are typically structured as defined contribution (DC) plans, such as Self-Invested Personal Pensions (SIPPs) and workplace pensions. These pensions provide individuals with a regular income during retirement based on accumulated contributions and investment growth over the years.
US 401(k)s: The US 401(k) is an employer-sponsored retirement plan. It operates as a defined contribution plan where employees can contribute a portion of their pre-tax income, often with an employer match. The accumulated funds in the account are invested, aiming to grow over time and provide income during retirement.
Contributions
UK Pensions: Contributions to UK pensions can come from various sources, including employees, employers, and the government. Employees can contribute from their pre-tax income; employers may match or make additional contributions. The government sets annual contribution limits, and tax relief is available on pension contributions, reducing an individual’s tax liability. The yearly allowance for most individuals to contribute is £40,000, a combined limit with a SIPP.
US 401(k)s: Contributions to 401(k) accounts are typically made by employees through salary deferrals. These contributions are made with pre-tax income, reducing the individual’s taxable income in the contribution year. Employers may also contribute through matching or profit-sharing contributions. The government sets annual contribution limits for 401(k) accounts. The limit for a 401(k) is $22,500
Taxation
UK Pensions: In the UK, contributions to pensions receive tax relief, meaning that individuals can contribute with pre-tax income. The growth within the pension account is tax-free, allowing investments to grow without incurring capital gains tax. However, withdrawals from the pension during retirement are subject to income tax.
US 401(k)s: Contributions to 401(k) accounts in the US are made with pre-tax income, providing an immediate tax benefit by reducing taxable income. The growth within the account is tax-deferred, meaning that investments can grow without being subject to capital gains tax. However, withdrawals from 401(k) accounts during retirement are subject to income tax. Some employers also offer options to make Roth contributions meaning after tax, where the Roth portion grows tax-free.
Access to Funds
UK Pensions: In the UK, individuals can generally access their pension funds from age 55, although this is expected to rise to age 57 by 2028. At retirement, there are various options for utilizing pension funds, including purchasing an annuity, taking a lump sum, or entering a drawdown arrangement to receive regular income while keeping the funds invested.
US 401(k)s: Withdrawals from 401(k) accounts in the US can generally be made penalty-free from the age of 59 ½. Early withdrawals before this age may be subject to a 10% early withdrawal penalty unless specific exceptions apply. Individuals can receive distributions in various ways, such as lump sum, periodic payments, or annuities.
SIPPS and Traditional IRAs
Purpose
SIPP: SIPPs are personal pension arrangements primarily focused on retirement savings. They are designed to provide individuals with a tax-efficient way to accumulate funds for retirement and offer more control and investment choices compared to traditional workplace pensions.
Traditional IRA: Traditional IRA is an account that allows someone to focus on saving for retirement.
Tax Treatment
SIPP: SIPP contributors receive tax relief, allowing individuals to contribute with pre-tax income. The government adds tax relief at the individual’s highest tax rate, meaning the government tops up contributions. The growth within a SIPP is tax-free. However, withdrawals from a SIPP during retirement are subject to income tax.
Traditional IRA: Traditional IRA contributors fund these with pre-tax income. This is a reduction in your payment for the year they file taxes.
Contribution Limits
SIPP: The annual contribution limit for SIPPs is based on the individual’s annual earnings or the annual allowance set by the government, whichever is lower. The yearly allowance for most individuals is £40,000, although it may be subject to tapering for high earners. The contribution limit is combined with an employer-sponsored pension for an annual allowance of £40,000.
Traditional IRA: The contribution limit for Traditional IRAs in the US is $6,500 (for individuals under 50 years old) or $7,500 (for individuals 50 years old or older) for the tax year 2023. Additional catch-up contributions are allowed for individuals aged 50 or older. This is the combined limit between the Roth IRA and Traditional IRA.
Access to Funds
SIPP: Funds in a SIPP are generally inaccessible until the individual reaches the minimum retirement age of 55. There are exceptions for specific circumstances, but early withdrawals from a SIPP are typically subject to significant penalties.
Traditional IRA: In the US, you can generally start withdrawing from a Traditional IRA penalty-free from the age of 59½. Withdrawals are subject to income tax. Early withdrawals (before age 59½) may be subject to a 10% early withdrawal penalty and income tax.
Investment Choices
SIPP: SIPPs provide even more significant investment flexibility and control. They allow individuals to invest in various assets, including stocks, bonds, mutual funds, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), commercial property, and more. SIPPs are particularly suited for those wanting to take a hands-on approach to managing retirement investments.
Traditional IRA: Traditional IRAs typically offer investment options, such as mutual funds, stocks, and bonds. The specific investment options available may depend on the IRA provider.
ISAs (UK) and Roth IRAs (US)
Purpose
ISA: ISAs are versatile investment accounts designed to help individuals save and invest for various financial goals, such as buying a home, saving for education, or building a general investment portfolio.
Roth IRA: Roth IRA is an account that allows someone to focus on saving for retirement. It is also very versatile in accessing it and the funds you use.
Tax Treatment
ISA: Contributions to ISAs are made with after-tax income, meaning there are no tax benefits for contributions. However, the growth within the ISA, including interest, dividends, and capital gains, is tax-free. Withdrawals from an ISA are also tax-free.
Roth IRA: Contributions to a Roth IRA are made with after-tax income, meaning there are no immediate tax deductions. The growth within a Roth IRA is tax-free, and qualified withdrawals in retirement are also tax-free.
Contribution Limits:
ISA: ISAs have an annual contribution limit set by the government, which changes yearly. For the tax year 2023/2024, the annual ISA contribution limit is £20,000.
Roth IRA: The contribution limit for Traditional IRAs in the US is $6,500 (for individuals under 50 years old) or $7,500 (for individuals 50 years old or older) for the tax year 2023. Additional catch-up contributions are allowed for individuals aged 50 or older. This is the combined limit between the Roth IRA and Traditional IRA.
Access to Funds:
ISA: Funds in an ISA can be accessed anytime without restrictions or penalties. Individuals can withdraw funds or contribute to the account as they wish.
Roth IRA: Contributions to a Roth IRA can be withdrawn without penalty, as they have already been taxed. However, withdrawing the investment growth before age 59½ may result in taxes and penalties unless it qualifies for certain exceptions.
Investment Choices:
ISA: ISAs offer various investment options, including cash deposits, stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and other eligible investments. The investment choices within an ISA may vary based on the provider.
Roth IRA: Roth IRAs match Traditional IRAs in investment options and typically offer investment options, such as mutual funds, stocks, and bonds. The specific investment options available may depend on the IRA provider.
To find out more about early retirement, check out our articles on retirement and investing.
Do you know what your FIRE Score is? Take our FIRE Quiz to see how close you are to FIRE.
Are you on the path to early retirement? How is it going? Feel free share in the comments!
To get the latest tips early retirement, make sure to subscribe to the MYB Retirement Club.
